This Week's Issue
News Opinion
Arts & Entertainment Comics
Sports Intramurals


Online Features
Speak Your Mind!
Planet of Sound

Archives / Search

About:
About the Yale Herald
About YH Online

Records: Tortoise's TNT

By Dan Wilchins

Critics often describe Chicago-based quintet Tortoise as experimental, which is unfortunate, because unlike most experimental rock groups, Tortoise is worth listening to. Millions Now Living Will Never Die (1996) was a riot of shifting time signatures, clattering marimbas and vibraharps, swirling melody lines, and unconventional chords. The songs were wordless, but Millions worked so well that you may never have noticed.

TNT feels much more laid back than Millions. The songs are slower, the melody lines gentler. Flamenco guitar stylings appear often, and coupled with the sampled sounds of children playing and waves crashing on "the equator," they give the album a decidedly Mediterranean, ambient feel.

Unfortunately, too much of TNT is ambient in the sense of muzak rather than Brian Eno. Tortoise boasts a roster of able soloists, but too often on TNT, they are content to noodle and repeat themselves. "Four-day Interval" begins with a theme played in unison; it starts off sounding like a Tony Williams Lifetime song from the mid-'70s. But soon after comes an aimless stretch of marimba playing, bass drum thumping, and analogue synthesizer gurgling, followed by a lengthy repetition of the theme. "The suspension bridge at iquazu falls," suffers from similar problems.

Tortoise does a good deal of experimentation on TNT. They use synthesizers more than they have before; some songs are almost entirely electronic. They also sample from different genres more extensively than they have in the past. In addition to the Jamaican dub bass lines that have long been a Tortoise mainstay, there are quasi- disco interludes, Spanish guitar work, and fusion segues on "almost always is nearly enough."

When Tortoise is actually experimenting, they are brilliant. But such moments are rare on TNT. The music here is percussive, different, difficult, and everything else you would expect of Tortoise. Unfortunately, it is also boring. (Thrill Jockey Records)

Back to A&E...


All materials © 1998 The Yale Herald, Inc., and its staff.
Got any questions, comments, or advice? Email the online editors at online@yaleherald.com.
Like to join us?